The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing


Subject:  Re: Roth IRA Contriubtions & Conversions Date:  2/2/1998  5:01 AM
Author:  Kilmarnoch Number:  1571 of 78166

tc001 wrote:
<<My question (as usual, if you've seen any of my posts on the tax board) is why the after-tax regular IRA
is being calculated as though the entire tax is paid at the marginal rate? Contributions are made at the
marginal rate, but withdrawals aren't necessarily so.>>

actually nothing is done at the marginal rate... everything is done at the effective rate. But the effective rate varies based on the exact dollar amount you make, and it is alot harder to explain to people who think of themselves "in the 28% bracket".

I think everyone is using the marginal rate because it is easy to do. I also think the results are useless. ;P

As far as the rate at retirement matching the rate at contribution, I think anyone who is *planning* for their retirement is not going to take too much of a tax bracket reduction after retirement. Most people who care what happens to themselves after retirement have a large amount of money saved away outside an IRA. Have you thought about what is going to happen to the tax rates when SS becomes a problem? Are you expecting tax rates to go *down* long term???

-- Later

I hope to be well above the 15% tax brac