The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Financial Planning / Tax Strategies


Subject:  Re: Tax Q&A 3/5/98 - Schedule D Date:  3/8/1998  6:09 PM
Author:  Travzila Number:  2502 of 127613

I've done some more research on this am convinced the calculations for my Schedule D are correct. Why? Because my long-term capital gains all occurred at times that resulted in me using my ordinary income tax rates.

The capital gains tax rates table at is a handy reference that led to my conclusion, and one to which I shall refer to below.

I had LT gains that occurred before 05/06/97, and as I fell into the 15% income tax bracket, the table shows that 15% is the tax rate for these LT gains.

I also had LT gains that occurred after 07/28/97 that were held more than 12 months but less than 18 months. Again, the table shows that the 15% income tax bracket uses the same 15% rate for computing taxes on these LT gains as well.

Roy Lewis' (author of the column) check calculation is line 17 = lines 36, 40, 46, and 50. Well, line 36 is for calculating a 10% tax rate (not applicable for me), line 40 is for calculating the 20% rate (not applicable for me), line 46 is for calculating the 25% rate (again, n/a for me) and, lastly, line 50 is for calculating the 28% tax rate (one final n/a for me).

Therefore, Roy Lewis' insistence that net capital gains in line 17 equal the total of lines 36, 40, 46, and 50 as always being true isn't a certainty. If anyone believes my reasoning to be incorrect, I challenge you to prove it with real numbers similar to the circumstances described above.

Copyright 1996-2018 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us