The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing


Subject:  Re: To: TMFPixy Date:  12/6/1998  9:31 AM
Author:  TMFPixy Number:  7055 of 88538

Greetings, Circa1950, and welcome. You wrote:

<<I am very appreciative of all the information, education, and assistance you offer. Much has been learned by scrolling through the messages on this board! I'm almost over-saturated with information and would like to have some objective (or "outside", at least) input about, or review of, some of the decisions/choices I've made, or still need to make. I'm late getting on board for "in earnest" retirement investing and also need to take into account maintaining savings for a college education for my kiddo in a few years. Hope this isn't too many questions at once:

1. I'm in a 401k (S&P Index Fund), maxing at 14%. My company matches 50% of my "regular contributions" which are considered the 1st 6%. This match is "always invested" in the company's stock (a rapidly changing industry). My contributions 1% Ă  14% goes to my fund of choice (the Index Fund);

2. I'm considering starting a Traditional IRA or ROTH IRA (Index, again) this year &/or $2,000 of stock purchases. I'm a bit confused re: Roth's vs. Traditional in terms of whether one or the other or both count as assets on applications for college tuition assistance (I posted this question on the Funding College board, but so far, no response). Thus, if a Traditional isn't counted and a Roth is, I'm thinking - in terms of preserving retirement - that I should go with a Traditional until there is no longer the college consideration.>>

There is still some element of confusion here regarding how school financial aid offices will treat the Roth IRA. Unlike a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA's contributions can be taken at any time. Hence, those contributions are available to pay for schooling with no tax or penalty impact. So far, the consensus among planners seems to be it will be up to the individual college financial aid offices as to whether these assets will or will not be counted. Only time will tell what happens in this regard.

<<3. I have a 403b from a previous job which I have left untouched. It clunked along pretty consistently at 11-12% (10 yr.returns to 9/30/97 = 17.93), then nose-dived 3rd quarter, 1998 (net loss $1,297.04; ending dollar value $6,738.16). Any suggestions including how-to advice for getting more "punch" out of this money would be most welcome.>>

No suggestions, but I will offer a comment. It seems you haven't moved this money to an IRA yet. You may want to consider doing so because you will have far greater flexibility in how you invest those funds within an IRA.


Copyright 1996-2018 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us