The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing


Subject:  Re: Help on 403 pleeze Date:  4/28/1999  4:13 PM
Author:  jocave Number:  10215 of 88763

We just dumped our tax-deferred annuity that was snail paced and moved about $80k into 403(B) mutual funds (we're teachers). We took a big hit for early withdrawal, and our "new" financial advisor put us into some high fee back loaded funds. That's the background, now here is the question.

First, a bit of confusion. 403(b) plans are qualified retirement plans (much like a 401(k)). One cannot simply roll an annuity into a 403(b). Was the rolled annuity previously part of another 403(b) plan?

We have our money in four mf companies -- Janus, AIM, Putnam, Oppenheimer. Lots of high fees in some of these funds. Regardless of their individual performance question is...are we spread too thin? Is four companies, with three mfs per company too many?

Depends on the criteria. You clearly have more funds than necessary for diversification purposes. It may be a pain for record-keeping purposes, though this is less important here than if they were held in a taxable brokerage account. If any of the funds charges a flat fee quarterly, annually, etc. rather than merely a % of assets, holding that many funds may well be financially wasteful.

I'm asking because we want to also now include a low-fee Vanguard Index fund but we're afraid we're spreading ourselves too thin. We can't pull the money and pay another withdrawal fine.

First, where are you going to hold this Index fund? If you're looking to buy in a taxable account, I'd say go for it-- no benefit to holding 1 fund in 2 accounts vs. 2 different funds in those same 2 accounts. If you're able to buy the fund through the 403(b), why not move some of the money invested in the other funds in the 403(b) to the Vanguard? Moving money between funds in a 403(b) shouldn't be a taxable event and shouldn't cause a fine. Of course, as per my initial comment, I'm a little confused as to exactly what your $80k is currently tied up in, which may severely impact this advice.
Copyright 1996-2018 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us