The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investment Analysis Clubs / Foolish Collective

URL:  http://boards.fool.com/hi-paulengr-interesting-questions-the-criteria-21721082.aspx

Subject:  Re: Selecting stocks the Ben Graham way Date:  12/8/2004  12:26 PM
Author:  StarryNightShade Number:  34770 of 46877

Hi PaulEngr,

Interesting questions.

The criteria are not mine, but those of Ben Graham. I take no credit or blame.

To answer your specific questions:

1) I'm in the midst of having just moved houses so I can't place my hands on BG's book to check, but I did correct for inflation. I don't know with certainly if the numbers quoted or in the BG book or the inflation adjusted ones. Although they do look like original ones.

6)The only adjustment I made is the one described for bond yields. PE's have risen but they've fallen too. The past 100 years has seen dramatic 30 year market cycles. If we are repeating this type of cycle it's possible we haven't seen the bottom of market PE's yet.

7)It's possible to adjust book value to include things like R&D to reflect a more "knowledge-based" (terrible term BTW) ec