The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing


Subject:  Re: is just investing in a S&P index fund for IR Date:  4/24/2006  12:55 AM
Author:  Matt1344 Number:  51359 of 78325

"is just investing in a S&P index fund for my IRA a good thing."

Hi kryszrich,

There's a lot of historical data on Crestmont site<>. It is for the S&P500 from 1900 to 2004/5.

The first chart can be looked at for several conditions, then pick any time period and see what the returns were:

You will find some rather long time frames of little or no returns, especially when inflation is taken into account. At least in the IRA you can disregard the chart that factors in taxes.

"Stock Matrix Options

Returns depend upon the starting and ending point. This series of charts present the compounded annual returns for an investor that began investing during any start year since 1900 and ending with any subsequent year. The versions presented reflect those for taxpayers (i.e. individuals, trusts, etc.) and for tax exempt or tax deferred investors (i.e. retirement accounts, pension plans, foundations, etc.), as well as returns on a nominal and real (after inflation) basis. The stock market index, dividend, and P/E ratio data is based upon the series developed and presented by highly acclaimed Professor Robert J. Shiller (Yale University; Irrational Exuberance) and others. Other data is developed from other sources believed to be reliable.
      Version       Single Page       Double Page      
Stock Index Only 11 x 17 8 1/2 x 11
Taxpayer Nominal 11 x 17 8 1/2 x 11