The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Retirement Discussions / Retire Early Liberal Edition


Subject:  Are Americans saving too much for retirement? Date:  2/17/2007  10:28 PM
Author:  SirTas Number:  2236 of 73799

This article claims that recent research suggests that the answer to the question is yes.

Some excerpts:

Conventional wisdom suggests that people are woefully unprepared for retirement. Study after study portrays most Americans as the proverbial grasshoppers, playing the fiddle with their finances while a minority of conscientious ants store up supplies for their golden years.

In 2004, for example, the Center for Retirement Studies at Boston College estimated that 43 percent of working households were in danger of having too little income to fund their retirement, even after tapping home equity.

Now a group of economists is offering a wildly contrarian view: People may be saving too much for their retirement. A few go so far as to suggest that the financial services industry is deliberately encouraging over-saving because it profits from managing such assets.

Consider a recent study conducted by Paul Smith and Lucy McNair of the Federal Reserve Board,