The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investment Analysis Clubs / Value Hounds


Subject:  Yongye v.2 corrected Q2 Date:  9/9/2012  1:48 PM
Author:  LeKitKat Number:  11538 of 24465

The highlight of Q2 has to be this exchange from the conference call.

Anson Beard – Private Investor—Advisory Director of Morgan Stanley
Sam, you're not answering the question. Did you write off last year $9 million? Is that a correct end of the year? You set a preserve for $15 million. You're reversing $6 million. Did you write off $9 million? Just yes or no.

Sam Yu
I'm sorry (inaudible).

Anson Beard
Right here in your cash flow statement for the six months ended, you show a negative $6 million because you put money back in from your reserve (inaudible) double accounts so I assume that the $15 million reserve – what?

Sam Yu

Anson Beard
It's 15 minus six.

Sam Yu
Inaudible) first quarter, yes.

The conversation encapsulates the problems investors have trying to make sense of this company and management’s inability to comprehend what they want.

The reversal of the reserve is interesting. They collected all overdue accounts and at the same time implemented a conservative revenue recognition policy whereby they do not recognize revenue from questionable accounts until some cash is received or the account has a history of reliable payments. It does not take the place of a reserve for doubtful accounts. They have historically managed to avoid having a reserve until the end of 2011, when they were castigated by the press and investors for allowing receivables to increase 471% year-over-year and days sales outstanding reached 10 months. Three months after creating the reserve, they reversed the %15.2 million by $6.3 million. That $6.3 million goes back on the profit and loss statement as a reduction in SG&A and lifts operating and net profits. The reserve still has $9 million. They did not take a charge of $9 million – it’s still there.

The reserve is a buffer to absorb defaults. If the reserve allowance is judged to be too high, part of the allowance can be reversed and the reserve gets smaller. The reversal of the non-cash charge is seen on the income statement as an expense decreases by the amount reversed.

June 30, 2012 June 30, 2011
Allowance for doubtful accounts
at beginning of period $15,222,584 0
Charged to bad debt expense 0 0
Reversal (6,334,832) 0
Foreign currency translation adjustment 112,076 0
Allowance for doubtful accounts
at end of period $8,999,828 0

Yongye’s receivables have improved significantly, but do continue to out pace revenue growth. Days sales outstanding (DSO) are higher than June 2011 even with the improved collections.

Jun-12 Mar-12 11-Dec 11-Sep 11-Jun
AR/revenue 106.1% 126.9% 342.4% 145.0% 92.1%
Receivables increase 32.2% 202.9% 471.6% 168.6% 161.1%
Revenue increase 14.8% 28.1% 60.3% 96.0% 73.0%
DSO 97 116 313 133 84

Businesses commonly increase the reserves over the years to match the increases in accounts receivables to ensure the buffer is adequate.

Since reserves decreased by 40%, the company must believe the ratio of reserve to receivables was too high. They do not have a history of reserves and normalized ratios for comparison. Every business is different. Yongye appears to believe they will have little trouble with collections.

Ratio of reserve/receivables:

December 2011 March 2012 June 2012
9.9% 10.9% 4.7%

The ratio is less than half what it was in December and March.

The impact of the reversal was seen on operating income and net in Q1 2012. With the extra $6 million added back, operating growth was 94%. If we don’t allow it back (it is non-cash) growth drops to 38% and that is without the new revenue recognition policy. It gives an idea of “real” growth.

Growth quarterly

Jun-12 Mar-12 11-Dec 11-Sep 11-Jun
Revenue 14.8% 28.1% 60.3% 96.0% 73.0%
Gross income 17.8% 26.0% 60.9% 103.3% 83.4%
Operating income 3.9% 37.8% 105.5% 142.9% 72.5%
Net income 4.1% 23.7% 66.6% 122.8% 62.9%

*Q1 results were adjusted for the reversal of reserves. It decreased operating and net income and slowed stated growth.

The new wrinkle to revenue recognition instituted in the second quarter is to not recognize a portion of revenue on shipment as they normally did. The company now identifies at risk and questionable accounts and will not put that revenue on the income statement until there is evidence the accounts will be paid.

Sam Yu

… a significant amount of profit associated with this unrecognized revenue was not booked, either. We estimate that without the revenue recognition issue our revenue and profit would have increased the profit 41% and 59% respe