The Motley Fool Discussion Boards
Health & Fitness / Low Carb Way of Life
|Subject: doubt on benefits of omega-3 supplements||Date: 9/12/2012 2:39 AM|
|Author: NailThatJello||Number: 29877 of 30089|
For years, major health and medical organizations have recommended fish oil supplements rich in omega-3s to reduce the threat of heart disease. Early trials of omega-3 supplements and cardiovascular health "showed strong, significant effect."
The new study, by medical researchers in Greece reexamined the results of 20 previous studies dating back to 1989 that included nearly 70,000 patients. As more randomized studies were performed, "the effect became weaker and nonsignificant."
Dr. Robert Bonow, a Chicago cardiologist who was not involved in the study, said he tended to agree with the authors' conclusion that not everyone would be helped by taking omega-3 supplements. Bonow said there was no evidence omega-3 prevented heart attacks and said that for most people, any potential benefits of supplementation probably paled in comparison with exercising, maintaining a proper weight and addressing high cholesterol and high blood pressure.
Most supplements only help you if your diet is deficient in that nutrient for some reason, no? If possible that would be the group to study - those whose diets are deficient vs those not. Large random groups would seem to swamp the data with noise.
OK then there may also be also certain theraputic situations like heart disease patients.
Lastly - I've heard that Omega 3 is also good for brain development.
|Copyright 1996-2013 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us|