The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Stocks B / Berkshire Hathaway


Subject:  Re: Still cheap at 4 year high Date:  10/5/2012  11:53 AM
Author:  mungofitch Number:  194677 of 218959

I also agree, however, with Jim's implication (at least I think he may
have implied it) that all of this anguished retrospection may tend to
induce some unfortunate bias in the reverse direction in the next big upswing in BRK's price.
Those of us who went through these experiences, and the subsequent
agonized reflection, last time, may be all too quick to sell out at 1.3
or 1.4 BV this time... which could prove to be another big mistake.

Gosh, I don't even have to say this stuff any more!
That's pretty much what I was thinking.
Plus the notion that maybe we were right last time and 1.5x is cheap and 1.7x is fair.

I will tell a worse mistake: BRK gets to 1.4x book, or $150-160k, and you
tell yourself that selling will be a big mistake, so you hold on.
Then, a few months later the stock market begins a new bear market...
Tell me how you would feel then about your decision to not sell at 1.4 x book?

I'd be clearheaded and happy.
It's not sensible to sell something at a price demonstrably below what
it's worth if you don't have a pressing need for the money.

Plus, if you are in a situation that you might have a pressing
need for the money you shouldn't have it in this or any other stock.
One's entire equity portfolio should be sized based on the assumption
that the market might drop 90% and stay there for 5 years.

A couple of statistical quirks that might be worth keeping in mind as people are reading this great thread.
Warning to pure value investors: price effects ahead.

- Though it may have no predictive power whatsoever, historically
when Berkshire gets into a rally it keeps going pretty steadily then stops abruptly.
Historically it has not paid to sell during such a rally, but rather
to wait for a pullback of at least 3% as a sign that the rally is over.
This is a particularly interesting notion if there is a rally into overvalued territory.

- If there are are people out there who are tired of waiting and start
selling too early at 1.3x or 1.4x, due to an interesting thing called
the "disposition effect" this will actually increase the momentum of the rally.
Though perhaps somewhat jagged and unpredictable, the momentum of the
rise in a stock will tend to be longer and stronger.
This isn't just mystical chartism, it falls out of the math when you
look at people who are anchoring on their entry prices and sell too