The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Politics & Current Events / Retire Early CampFIRE


Subject:  Re: Get Ready For The oUtRaGe! Date:  1/12/2013  5:55 PM
Author:  CCinOC Number:  666085 of 875651

The Myth of the Robber Barons

This book describes the role of key entrepreneurs in the economic growth of the United States from 1850 to 1910. The entrepreneurs studied are Cornelius Vanderbilt, John D. Rockefeller, James J. Hill, Andrew Mellon, Charles Schwab, and the Scranton family. Most historians argue that these men, and others like them, were Robber Barons. The story, however, is more complicated. The author, Burton Folsom, divides the entrepreneurs into two groups: market entrepreneurs and political entrepreneurs. The market entrepreneurs, such as Hill, Vanderbilt and Rockefeller, succeeded by producing a quality product at a competitive price. The political entrepreneurs such as Edward Collins (in steamships and in railroads; the leaders of the Union Pacific Railroad) were men who used the power of government to succeed. They tried to gain subsidies or in some way use government to stop competitors.

The market entrepreneurs helped lead to the rise of the U. S. as a major economic power. By 1910, the U. S. dominated the world in oil, steel, and railroads led by Rockefeller, Schwab, Carnegie and Hill. The political entrepreneurs, by contrast, were a drain on the taxpayers and a thorn in the side of the market entrepreneurs.

Interestingly, the political entrepreneurs often failed; without help from government they could not produce competitive products. The author describes this clash of the market entrepreneurs and the political entrepreneurs.

In the Mellon chapter, the author describes how Andrew Mellon, an entrepreneur in oil and aluminum, became Secretary of Treasury under Coolidge. In office, Mellon was the first American to practice supply-side economics. He supported cuts on income tax rates for all groups.

The rate cut on the wealthiest Americans, from 73 percent to 25 percent, freed up investment capital and led to American economic growth during the 1920s. Also, the amount of revenue into the federal treasury increased sharply after tax rates were cut. [Well, whaddya know.]

The Myth of the Robber Barons has separate chapters on Vanderbilt, Hill, Schwab, Mellon and the Scrantons. The author also has a conclusion, in which he looks at the textbook bias on the subject of Robber Barons and the rise of the U. S. in the late 1800s. This chapter explores three leading college texts in U. S. history and shows how they misread American history and disparage market entrepreneurs instead of the political entrepreneurs. This book is in its fifth edition, and is widely adopted in college and high school classrooms across the U. S.

Let's not forget about Andrew Carnegie, who endowed this nation's library sytstem to the betterment of Americans of every class. He was also one of the highest profile philanthropists of his era. His 1889 article "Wealth" (known more commonly—-particularly in colloquial parlance—-as "The Gospel of Wealth") remains a formative advisory text for those who aspire to lead philantropic lives.
Copyright 1996-2018 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us