The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing


Subject:  Re: Strategy comparison S&P500 vs. IUL [rev 1] Date:  4/4/2013  6:44 PM
Author:  Dwdonhoff Number:  71709 of 88520

Hi Ray,

How much is that 5% spread out over 20, 30, 40 years?
Quite a lot, actually. Compounding over a period of several decades has a far more major effect than people generally realize.

It is true that a one-time 5% fee compounded forward grows large... but the 2-3% ongoing annual fees/costs required to get the same zero-floor market gains outside an IUL compound to dramatically more than the 5% one-time compounded.

If we're not going to compare feature apples-to-apples, why not just bury cash in a coffee can... its free *AND* safe?

I wonder, though, if that 17% is contractually guaranteed.
The 17% figure she's brought up at Allianz is on a blended index of several markets. The structured options have significantly lower premium costs and their internally hedged returns outperform the S&P options alone.

The caps are held as high as the markets force them. Every carrier is subject to;
a) attracting new business,
b) keeping as much cash value inside existing business,
c) avoiding lawsuits by an unhappy customer base declaring ungrounded unfair dealing.

Carriers *have* tried to bring existing books of established contracts down in caps below the competitive insutry norm, only to face an onslought of litigative hell... from which all of the industry has observed & learned. They play it as conservatively as they can, in general.



While you accounted for homeowner's insurance and property taxes, you didn't account for all those other expenses

You are right... I ballparked too quickly. This just happened to be numbers from a similar inquiry I had received yesterday, and I need to build it out. When I do, I'll bring it here.

The lifestyle expenses have to be accounted for.
The 18% savings by eliminating the consumer debt will add positive weight.
It will still result in the 5 yr ARM being superior I expect... but we'll see.

Dave Donhoff
Leverage Planner
Copyright 1996-2018 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us