The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Social Clubs / Deranged Monkey Criticism

URL:  http://boards.fool.com/didnt-you-learn-anything-from-our-ongoing-convo-30683443.aspx

Subject:  Re: Poll: Technical Analysis Date:  5/14/2013  2:12 PM
Author:  DrtThrwingMonkey Number:  17116 of 21596

Didn't you learn anything from our ongoing convo with the technicals on NFLX back in 2011? :)

Either I'm not understanding what you are saying here, or you are not understanding my point. Not sure which is which? Did you read the link discussing TSLA?

Of course, one cannot in advance forecast which bases will breakout or breakdown when or continue to stay in the base. TA is NOT a crystal ball!!!



I'm not sure I understand what you mean. It may not be a crystal ball (I understand those things are infallible), but does it have predictive power? If you really can't tell which ones will break out and which ones will stay in the base, then I'm not getting why this would be useful to do.

As for not learning anything from NFLX, I was very happy to get out of that one with my skin, but I eventually closed my short position with a manageable loss, largely because it seemed crazy betting against a solid company, even if it was overvalued. I can't give much credit to TA for that one. I guess I'm probably a hopeless case.

But I do sense a pattern in your posts: I should have seen this thing, but I'm too busy. OK, say I send you the thing that you were too busy to see, so you get a second chance, but I remove the info about whether it eventually went up or stayed the same for a while or went down. Say I send you a hundred of these things. Are you really saying there would be no way to judge whether you get these right or not? For someone with an engineering background, that seems mysterious.

DTM
Trying to keep an open mind, but the biblical figure I always sympathized with most was Doubting Thomas
Copyright 1996-2014 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us