The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Financial Planning / Tax Strategies

URL:  http://boards.fool.com/after-learning-that-having-two-ira-accounts-and-30749989.aspx

Subject:  Re: Converted Just One of Two IRAs to a Roth Date:  6/26/2013  2:00 AM
Author:  IMBonzi Number:  118748 of 123001

After learning that having two IRA accounts and converting only one of them to a Roth creates ongoing tax problems,

I have never heard of this before. Either you've misinterpreted something or we have radically different concepts of what a problem is. Could you please elaborate on the nature of this problem and why a partial Roth conversion creates it?

The problem, if I understood what I was reading, is that the IRS considers lumps all IRA’s of an individual together when determining the tax on a conversion to a Roth. The accountant writing this warned that taxes on a partial conversion continue to be levied in succeeding years. It only just now occurred to me the previous reply that this should apply only where IRA’s contained deductible as well as nondeductible contributions, which mine do not.

I recharacterized the IRA contributory to Roth conversion that I made in 2012.

We need to pause and clarify here since "IRA contributory" doesn't mean anything in tax speak. What did you recharacterize, a contribution or a conversion? I'm assuming it's a conversion, but I just want to be sure.

Yes. It was a conversion.

Unfortunately I learned about the problem at the last minute and, though I gave online instructions to my broker to transfer the money back to my IRA before April 15, 2013, the transfer was not completed until April 15th. I received a Form 5498 for the IRA to Roth conversion.

Relax. You have until 10/15/2013 to complete a 2012 recharacterization. See the instructions for Form 8606.

I was/am under the impression that had I transferred the money back to my IRA before April 15, 2013, I could have considered the conversion to the Roth as never having been made, and thus would not have had to recharacterize it and then pay more tax on the larger amount I had after the recharacterization when I converted it again to the Roth.

Turbotax does not seem to recognize the problem of converting just one of two IRA accounts to a Roth. It must recognize that something is wrong, however, because it tells me I will have to pay a penalty for having too much income to have made the conversion in the first place.

Leave poor TT out of this. I recognize that something is wrong because

1. There is no income limit for Roth conversions and
2. You have somehow told TT that the conversion was a contribution.

Find it and fix it.