The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing

URL:  http://boards.fool.com/my-previous-post-was-wrong-i-had-a-brainfade-in-30871178.aspx

Subject:  Re: Hi gang... wow!!! Date:  9/15/2013  5:53 AM
Author:  Rayvt Number:  72851 of 76421

My previous post was wrong. I had a brainfade; in trying to make a fair comparison I went overboard. The deposit is $150/mo, period. The internal fees (policy fees & mortality charge) of the IUL are just that -- internal fees of that account and are completely accounted for in the expense/fee field. The life insurance is of no benefit to the account holder -- it's a throwaway -- therefore it is not appropriate to reduce the monthly deposit of the B&H account by that amount.
The monthly deposit is $150, period.

Using various different asset allocations for the S&P500 B&H portfolio.
X% S&P500 / Y% 10-yr T-bill
initial deposit $15,000, monthly addition $150, No tax on dividends.

Jan 1963 start.
100/0: Value at end of 50 years (Jan 2013): $3,480,000 MaxDrawdown: -46% Stdev: 15.3%
60/40: Value at end of 50 years (Jan 2013): $2,514,000 MaxDrawdown: -30% Stdev: 9.2%
50/50: Value at end of 50 years (Jan 2013): $2,260,000 MaxDrawdown: -25% Stdev: 7.7%
IUL value: $1,104,000

The worst case drop was from the peak on Nov'07 to the bottom on Mar'09.
Account values at the Mar'09 bottom:
100/0: $1,804,000
60/40: $1,605,000
50/50: $1,524,000
IUL: $838,000

*********
Jan 1973 start.
100/0: Value at end of 40 years (Jan 2013): $1,500,000
60/40: Value at end of 40 years (Jan 2013): $1,122,000
50/50: Value at end of 40 years (Jan 2013): $1,023,000
IUL value: $586,000

Account values at the Mar'09 bottom:
100/0: $775,000
60/40: $714,000
50/50: $687,000
IUL: $442,000

*********
Jan 1963 start for 40 years.
100/0: Value at end of 40 years (Jan 2003): $1,766,000
60/40: Value at end of 40 years (Jan 2003): $1,400,000
50/50: Value at end of 50 years (Jan 2003): $1,295,000
IUL value: $559,000
Copyright 1996-2014 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us