(based on your wording it seems like you would advise OP against the idea of after-tax contributions to her 401k too).Correct. I find it too much work and not enough benefit to do such gyrations.To clarify, my suggestion is to check the option of doing a back-door Roth contribution by putting money into a traditional IRA (not mentioned originally) and converting to Roth IRA. With the contribution limits of the IRAs, she would still have funds to save in a taxable account.Thanks for the clarification as I was not understanding that this was your suggestion. That said, I don't care for this suggestion either. I keep going back to not understanding the motivation to stuff everything into a tax-deferred retirement vehicle because it locks too much money in those accounts that you cannot access until 59 1/2 without paying a penalty to get to your own money. Given that the funds are after tax anyhow, I would much prefer to just leave them that way and maintain the flexibility of being able to use my own money whenever I please for whatever I please without having to worry about paying a penalty for the privilege. I think that if you are investing for capital gain, you're better off to pay the capital gains tax rate in a taxable account than what will probably be higher ordinary taxes when you take money from an IRA.There is nothing magic about a retirement savings account that requires all retirement money to be in one. You can still use your taxable account for retirement money later.As far as the back-door Roth conversion, there are rules around that as well if you have other funds in a Traditional IRA, but someone else will have to spell those out. I do know that it is not falling off a log to do this conversion, and there can be other tax ramifications.It just seems to me that all these gyrations are not necessary. Just leave after-tax dollars in a taxable account, and invest as part of the entire portfolio.
Best Of |
Favorites & Replies |
Start a New Board |
My Fool |
BATS data provided in real-time. NYSE, NASDAQ and NYSEMKT data delayed 15 minutes.
Real-Time prices provided by BATS. M