|
Recommendations: 4
So it has taken me a couple of days to digest and analyze the CMG
report from last Thursday. I am not going to rehash the quarterly
results but I will say that despite the market and analyst reaction
I still believe that the maangement team is demonstrating operational
excellence.
What I have done is gone back to my financial statement model and
updated the quarterly numbers and made some adjustments to the
future years based on the information provided on the call and in
the report. I then ran the numbers using some high expectations (H)
normal expectations (E), and low expectations (L). In addition
I used some expected valuations that the market might provide CMG.
My CAGR was based on the July 24th closing price of $294.31/share
and was for a 54 month period since YE 2016 results will probably
be available at that time.
2016
H E L
REVENUE 6,598,000 6,141,000 4,902,000
NET INCOME 663,120 584,660 441,150
EPS 20.33 17.94 13.51
VALUATION 35 25 15
SHARE PRICE 711.52 448.44 202.71
SP CAGR 21.7% 9.8% -8.0%
OK I can do basic tables after 1,000 posts (Yipee!)!
So you can see that it appears that at today's price, CMG may still
be a little overvalued and might not provide an adequate return for
the risks involved. I might even be a little generous in my the
valuation I provided in my expected sceniaro. While it is true that
if CMG achieves $17.94 in EPS by YE 2016, that will be a 22%
compounded increase on EPS from YE 2011. The market may not be
willing to believe that the growth story will continue and provide
a premiume (much like it appears to be doing today).
To get to my "E" numbers I had 2,416 units including approximately
15 European locations and 35 Canadian locations. I also had
72 Shophouse units operating with similar economics to CMG
units. So if you believe that 3,000 domestic units is about the
saturation point for CMG, there would still be approximately
750 units to build.
To get to my "H" estimates, I had 2,781 units in the system.
Inlcuded in that number were 250 Shophouse units operating
with similar economics as CMG and 100 international locations
with 1/4 in Europe and the rest in Canada.
My "L" numbers were based off a unit count of 2,261. There are
only 60 Shophouse and international locations combined.
So if you believe like I do that CMG stock will be about
$450/share in 4.5 years, I would like to see today's share price
get to $275 before I would be buying. This would provide an
estiamted 12% CAGR for the next 4.5 years which I think is an
acceptable estimated return for CMG.
I also ran the 2017 estimates.
2017
H E L
REVENUE 8,248,000 7,492,000 5,465,000
NET INCOME 828,900 714,110 505,200
EPS 25.28 21.80 15.40
VALUATION 35 25 15
SHARE PRICE 884.97 545.01 230.98
SP CAGR 22.2% 11.9% -4.3%
So I will admit, I am not completely sure why the CAGRs for my
estimated share prices went up so much. I actually have slowing
growth built into the E model due to the fact that new store
openings will have a smaller impact on overall sales as the
base gets bigger. Yet, I look at these estimates and I can
begin to make a case for purchasing CMG at today's levels.
If anyone can explain this, I would appreciate it!
Conclusion
I think CMG is a well operated company with plenty of growth
ahead of it. I think the market was overvaluing this growth
until Friday and now it is bringing the share price down to a
level where purchasing shares may make sense. I am long CMG
and will probably put a limit order in for a purchase of shares
around $275/share.
Fool on!
Bruiser
|
|
|
Announcements
|