GlennRim,Many of your replies raised useful points IMHO.When you wrote the following you were offering your opinion:Actually, I own the game both computer and card-table versions. I bought them simultaneously, in an effort to find out if he really had anything to offer to a novice. The games are interesting, but hardly educational. They are unrealistic in many ways. They don't represent reality in any meaningful way. I will admit that the card-table version is somewhat enjoyable to play, especially with a few folks who have some time to waste. The computer version (both 101 and 202) is rather the opposite, in my opinion, it's boring, simplistic, and silly. I think they are nothing more than a game. They lack an ability to teach anything of value about finances.Having watched 1 person in detail and a few others more at a distance I can honestly say that the games and the books have changed their financial lives. Much more so than any more formal text on finances. Not sure if they would have had any interest in reading a more formal or classical text on finances.The game (101 is all I am talking about) is not going to change the world for everyone. You and I are clearly two people who were past the level the game targets. It does change the world for some so the value is more than just a way to pass time.The fact alone that there are a number of clubs around the world who play and engage in discussions about how the game concepts play out in real life is enough of an example.No text or game will ever be complete or perfect for educating a person on the world of finance. A game or book that gets someone started and otherwise motivated to follow up with more study is a great contribution IMHO.John Corey
Best Of |
Favorites & Replies |
Start a New Board |
My Fool |
BATS data provided in real-time. NYSE, NASDAQ and NYSEMKT data delayed 15 minutes.
Real-Time prices provided by BATS. Market data provided by Interactive Data.
Company fundamental data provided by Morningstar<