<<Ramtough wrote>>I'm looking for the answer to a question that has probably been asked a million times. I would like know which vehicle is the better option for someone with about 10 years before retirement. I have an existing Traditional but I want to know if I should continue to invest in it or start a new Roth. Are there any sites on the web that address this exact question. I would be interested in a site that is interactive.<<Pixy replied in part>>Which would be better is largely contingent on your tax status today versus that ten years from now. If your marginal tax rate stays the same and rates of return are the same in both IRA, then it's a wash. If your tax rate will be lower ten years from now, the traditional IRA is better. It the tax rate is higher, then the Roth is better.<<my comment>>Pixy, I'm with you on your first sentence but not the second one -- at least, if you take advantage of the effectively larger size of the Roth IRA by making the full contribution. If your tax rate stays the same, and you maximize your contributions to the Roth IRA, you'll come out ahead (and by a significant margin when the time frame is 10 years). Throw in a couple of other goodies like the ability to make early withdrawals of contributions without penalty or tax, and the ability to leave money in after age 70-1/2, and the Roth IRA looks even better.Here's my rule of thumb (not original with me, but one I have adopted because I believe it works): choose the deductible IRA over the Roth IRA if your deduction will be at 28% or higher and your withdrawals will come when you are in the 15% bracket. It's hard to project that the benefits of the Roth IRA will overcome a 13% rate differential. Otherwise choose the Roth IRA (even if your rate will shift from 31% to 28%). I emphasize that this is only a rule of thumb and there are many more considerations laid out at length on my web site. But you're missing an important factor if you suggest that the two forms of IRA are a wash for someone whose tax rate remains the same.KAT in Chicagolandhttp://www.fairmark.comTax Guide for InvestorsNow with expanded and revised Roth IRA information
Best Of |
Favorites & Replies |
Start a New Board |
My Fool |
BATS data provided in real-time. NYSE, NASDAQ and NYSEMKT data delayed 15 minutes.
Real-Time prices provided by BATS. Market data provided by Interactive Data.
Company fundamental data provided by Morningstar. Earnings Estimates, Analyst Ra