No. of Recommendations: 18
JasperCapital said: that kind of illiquidity makes a good case for not going into those kinds of issues at all.

JC, "You can check out anytime you like, but you can never leave” is a fairly accurate description for REIT preferred owners. They are one of the most illiquid investment options that are regularly traded. I would not include them in the same category as life insurance, annuities, hedge funds and/or partnerships. But they are EXTREMELY thinly traded compared to most common stocks. They are MORE liquid that trading individual bonds.

For example, today (2/8/13), the median volume for REIT preferreds was 4,899 shares. Of issues >=$5.00 per share, 14 did NOT trade today. This is fairly common and some of the same issues regularly show up on the do NOT trade list.

Related to this is how wide the bid-ask spread is. In cases like the one I documented with the “One Share Club”, the bid-ask spread can be up to $1.00. This is NOT the norm. Maybe 10% of the most liquid issues trade with a 1 cent bid-ask spread. Since the bid-ask spread is constantly changing over during the trading day, it is difficult to quantify it with a single number. My guess is that a 5 to 7 cent spread is about the median.

The other part of this is “how deep the book” is. That means how many orders to buy, at what price and volume there are. Same for orders to sell. Let me illustrate with an example. With a broad brush, if you placed a 5,000 “market” buy order on any issue, you would buy every single share up to the “stub quote.” The “stub quote” is the dummy price that dealers use. Recall during the flash crash that issues traded for both 1 cent and $99,999. Those were stub quotes at the time. After the flash crash, dealers “tightened up” their stub quotes. That is where the ~$33.00 ask price shows up for $25 REIT preferreds. If you placed the 5,000 share buy order, probably the last 2,000 to 4,000 shares would be at $33.00. Once again, I am using generalities to make the point.

I have actually done this “experiment” several times with real money. Sometimes is was purposeful and one time it was an accident. For example, I might place a market buy order for 1,000 shares to see how it got filled. I have seen several cases where the fill range was ~$1.00 wide.

All of this reinforces the illiquidity of REIT preferreds. Investors have to understand this as part of the game if they are going to invest in them. Several times, REIT board followers have taken advantage of the illiquidity to buy temporarily depressed prices. That is fine and good.

There are broadly three types of REIT preferred holders:

1) That yield sure is great! I don’t understand calls. I don’t understand Yield to First Call. I have no idea how or when I would ever sell one of them. Have I told you how great the yield is?

2) I have a belief that interest rates will NOT spike and that I can comfortably hold REIT preferreds for the long term. The biggest risk I see is that they will be called away and I will have to reinvest at a lower yield. I understand Yield to First Call and sell issues that become irrationally priced. Sometimes I trade from one issue to the other to maximize current income.

3) I think I can spot the rising interest rate/inflation fire before everybody else. I think I can get out of the door safely before the pileup occurs. If I am wrong, I understand that I might suffer a capital loss if I sell the issue. In the meantime, I will still enjoy the high coupon yield. I might choose to hold, even if the prices go down substantially.

The question is what would happen when/if the REIT board decided to sell all? Let’s say we got a divine “Sell All REIT Preferreds” today signal. In round numbers, there are about 25 REITsters. Let’s assume they all owned the same issues. Let’s also assume they own an average of 1,000 shares per person. So we are trying to sell 25,000 shares at the same time on issues that trade ~ 5,000 shares per day. We are attempting to do 5 days of trading in one day. The prices would drop significantly. Gun to my head, I would expect the price to go down 5% to 15% in one day. Once again, this is very broad. Some issues trade a lot more and could take the 25,000 shares and NOT move the price very much.

At the other extreme, if you tried to sell 25,000 shares of my bellowed long call date SPGPRJ, PPSPRA and/or PLDGP, you would absolutely, positively HIT the lower stub quote. Matter of fact, I suspect that the dealers would turn their algorithms off and you would NOT be able to sell that many shares at any price. These are the issues that have first call dates of at least 13 years from now. As REITnut would say “they trade by appointment.”

Yoda might be incredibly foolish, yet we DO own SPGPRJ, PPSPRA and PLDGP in widows and orphans funds. Hopefully we understand the risks and know what we are in for. It is very important IMO that investors understand these risks before they buy any REIT preferreds with a substantial allocation. Buying them might mean you just checked into the Hotel California.



Here is a table of REIT preferreds plus their volume for 2/8/13.

GGPYP 540,350
NLY-PD 376,574
WRI-PD 263,270
DDR-PH 111,532
CDR-PB 89,940
PSA-PO 86,924
PSA-PP 62,324
ELS-PC 51,581
RPAI-pA 50,700
VNO-PH 49,035
NRF-PC 48,769
CLNY-PA 44,423
PSB-PT 34,988
PSA-PT 32,541
NLY-PA 32,279
GRT-PG 32,127
VNO-PL 31,488
ARR-PA 28,360
SNHN 28,159
LHO-PG 27,133
KIM-PJ 26,744
NLY-PC 25,612
VNO-PK 25,441
HTS-PA 24,833
PSB-PU 24,596
NRF-PB 24,141
AGNCP 24,124
PSA-PV 23,997
BEE-PC 22,038
EPR-PF 21,919
KRC-PH 21,235
DDR-PJ 20,678
ANH-PB 20,455
VNOD 19,786
SHO-PA 19,400
COR-PA 18,228
KIM-PH 17,797
SLG-PI 17,545
PSA-PR 16,731
AMTG-PA 16,547
PEI-PB 16,405
INN-PB 15,720
RAS-PA 15,713
IVR-PA 15,438
AHT-PE 15,378
VNO-PJ 14,346
TCO-PJ 14,284
FCH-PA 14,262
RSO-PB 13,383
RAS-PB 13,211
AREEP 12,731
SFI-PD 12,561
PSA-PQ 11,647
PSA-PS 11,117
CDR-PA 10,937
FR-PK 10,899
CMO-PB 10,365
MFO 10,319
HPT-PD 10,112
PSB-PS 9,990
IRC-PA 9,873
CYS-PA 9,494
CWHO 9,471
WRT 9,330
DLR-PE 9,107
O-PF 8,561
O-PE 8,531
EPR-PC 8,371
WRD 8,367
VNO-PI 8,044
PSA-PU 7,794
CWHN 7,668
BIR-PA 7,538
IRET-PB 7,510
REG-PF 7,244
CBL-PD 7,146
ARI-PA 7,075
BEE-PA 7,012
DFT-PB 7,003
DLR-PF 6,973
MITT-PB 6,950
KIM-PI 6,926
HPT-PC 6,832
DRE-PO 6,690
SFI-PE 6,520
MITT-PA 6,400
RAS-PC 6,310
HCN-PJ 6,144
CWH-PD 6,011
KRG-PA 5,902
WRI-PF 5,850
BFS-PA 5,646
GRT-PH 5,626
HT-PA 5,448
CBL-PE 5,445
CWH-PE 5,443
DRE-PJ 4,980
PEI-PA 4,817
HCN-PI 4,631
GKK-PA 4,460
NNN-PD 4,115
CHSP-PA 4,056
LSE-PA 4,047
SUI-PA 3,843
ARE-PE 3,450
FUR-PD 3,328
AHT-PD 3,164
SFI-PG 3,100
VNO-PG 3,065
SFI-PI 3,028
BMR-PA 2,970
FCH-PC 2,719
LHO-PH 2,700
CCG-PA 2,697
DFT-PA 2,598
EXL-PB 2,400
LSE-PC 2,400
INN-PA 2,400
DRE-PK 2,393
MPG-PA 2,303
RSO-PA 2,272
NCT-PB 2,225
OFC-PL 2,190
PEB-PA 2,100
ANH-PA 1,995
NRF-PA 1,957
PSB-PR 1,900
PLD-PS 1,850
AIV-PZ 1,815
VNO-PF 1,700
MNR-PB 1,527
UMH-PA 1,500
REG-PG 1,465
ESS-PH 1,451
RPT-PD 1,400
UBP-PD 1,300
GOODP 1,285
BEE-PB 1,280
CUZ-PA 1,220
PPS-PA 1,203
TRNO-PA 1,200
BFS-PB 1,164
BDN-PE 1,100
NCT-PC 1,100
LXP-PC 1,085
EPR-PE 1,000
LXP-PD 1,000
FPO-PA 1,000
MNR-PA 1,000
LSE-PB 950
KRC-PG 900
BRE-PD 900
SLG-PC 868
DRE-PL 862
UBP-PF 835
CUZ-PB 805
HT-PB 800
SFI-PF 800
PLD-PR 550
MFA-PA 525
PEB-PB 500
HPP-PB 450
IRET-pA 400
NHC-PA 353
FR-PJ 300
OFC-PJ 200
PLD-PO 200
DX-PA 100
PKY-PD 100

Print the post  


Related Boards
Real Estate Investing
This is a great board for Real Estate other than REITs.

Buying & Selling a Home
Get your personal advice about mortgages, agents, etc. here.
What was Your Dumbest Investment?
Share it with us -- and learn from others' stories of flubs.
When Life Gives You Lemons
We all have had hardships and made poor decisions. The important thing is how we respond and grow. Read the story of a Fool who started from nothing, and looks to gain everything.
Community Home
Speak Your Mind, Start Your Blog, Rate Your Stocks

Community Team Fools - who are those TMF's?
Contact Us
Contact Customer Service and other Fool departments here.
Work for Fools?
Winner of the Washingtonian great places to work, and Glassdoor #1 Company to Work For 2015! Have access to all of TMF's online and email products for FREE, and be paid for your contributions to TMF! Click the link and start your Fool career.