Message Font: Serif | Sans-Serif

 Author: Rayvt Number: of 73923 Subject: Re: Hi gang... wow!!! Date: 9/16/2013 7:26 PM
 Post New | Post Reply | Reply Later | Create Poll Report this Post | Recommend it!
Recommendations: 5
 then it's risk-adjusted returns are its gross returns times 1-drawdown. There are a bunch of standard ways that risk-adjusted returns are calculated.Average return divided by MaxDD is not one of those ways.In fact, MaxDD is virtually useless because it is just a measure of the one-time worst case event.CalMar, StdDev, Sortino, Sharpe, Ulcer Index, Ulcer Performance Index -- these are all common measures.Just eyeballing the 40 year balance on the IUL I ran, versus the 40 year balance on the spreadsheet... looks to me like the IUL finishes with more money.The spreadsheet uses actual historical data.I can't cut-paste from your pdf, but it says, "reflect a hypothetical rate at the average historical rates". I don't see anywhere where they state what the rate they used. So you cannot compare the two, since one uses real data and the other uses an average.How *did* you create that PDF? I can't cut/paste from it, which is rather annoying. [...sounds of typing, grumbling in the background...]YES! HA! WHO'S THE MAN!Got it!I checked the Illustration at 4 different dates 10 years apart, and every one computed as an annual gain of 8.8%.This illustration is garbage and arguably fraudulent. They don't show any years where the return is zero, nor any years where the return is 12%. Yet we know from the historical data that 25% of the annual returns are < 0% (and therefore would be floored at 0%) and 45% of the annual returns are > 12% (and therefore would be capped at 12%)In order to do a like-to-like comparison, you'd have to compare their illustration with a S&P500 B&H spreadsheet with a fixed 10.8% annual return. Or 9.2% for a 60/40 asset allocation.Oh, hmmm, very interesting. My spreadsheet computes the CAGR for the IUL portfolio and it computes as [....drum roll ....] 7.0% to 8.5%, depending on the exact starting date. So it appears they not only bogusly used a constant annual gain, but they put a bit of thumb on the scale.
 Post New | Post Reply | Reply Later | Create Poll Report this Post | Recommend it!
Discussion on accelerating retirement day.
Foolanthropy 2013 Kicks Off!
"Pencils of Promise works with communities across the globe to build schools and create programs that provide education opportunities for children -- no matter where they were born or what resources they have." The Motley Fool is a champion of education, and we are proud to be associated with this effort!
2.55 Million User Names Released!
Fools, over the years a lot of user names have been taken, then fell into disuse. We have released the user names that are no longer current, so if you have a more preferred user name you want to try, now is the time to snag it!
New Fool-Branded Credit Card Available!
How does your card compare to ours?
Be a fan of the Fool over on Facebook!
Post of the Day:
Macro Economics

On How the CRIC Became a Growth Investor