The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing

URL:  https://boards.fool.com/is-a-401k-a-bad-choice-for-us-20258675.aspx

Subject:  Is a 401k a bad choice for us? Date:  2/3/2004  9:57 AM
Author:  Hauptstrasse94 Number:  38907 of 92411

I don't think a 401k is the best choice for us in this situation. Does anyone have experience/advice related to this?

I have always followed the advice repeated unfailingly to the newly employed. I started investing in my 401k right out of college without really knowing why, but now that I'm 32 I am quite glad I did. I opened a Roth IRA which I keep fully funded, and my husband does the same.

My husband just got a job that will require him to basically live in Kuwait for the next 12 months or so. This means he will be earning his first $80K free from federal taxes (with no local/foreign tax implications). We have discussed the idea of participating in his company's 401k but came to the conclusion that it makes no sense. Would that not just be saving money tax-free so we could pay taxes on it later? Since the money is already tax-free, why not invest it in something that does not require paying taxes on the principal upon withdrawal?

That also leads me to my next question- what types of investments are good to consider when we're not looking for a tax-advantaged savings account?

-Kristin

Copyright 1996-2019 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us