The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Personal Finances / Credit Cards and Consumer Debt


Subject:  Re: Maybe it's genetic Date:  12/7/2012  9:46 PM
Author:  NoIDAtAll Number:  306498 of 312536

Actually the use and possible misuse of genetic testing is a scarey potential problem in many areas of life. The problem for mis-use is similar to the problem of Insurance Companies using auto insurance applicants FICO scores to rate and price insurance policy products. They use the FICO scores simply because: 1. They exist, and 2. they are inexpensive for an insurance company to obtain from the UnFair-Issac corporation. FICO scores were NEVER designed to ever rate insurance risk of any kind yet they are frequently used that way. There used to be a term: "There Out to be a Law". In this case State Insurance Commissioners could simply administratively prohibit insurance companies from accessing applicants for insurance FICO Scores.

Kahuna, CFA
Venture Capital
Founding General
Partner 96745

Not to mention that the statistical correlation has proven accurate over time, and has saved quite a LOT of people quite a lot, while causing risks who are more prone to incurring claims to pay more of their share of losses they incur. (You really should stick to something that you may actually know something about, whatever that may be - This ain't one of them.):

It is beyond debate that the use of credit-based insurance scoring models can provide lift to insurers in the underwriting and rating processes. The correlation between a person’s credit characteristics and that person’s propensity to have insurance losses has been demonstrated by several credible multivariate analyses. As the Federal Trade Commission and several states’ studies have shown, credit-based insurance scoring models are demonstrably efficient and accurate in predicting insurance losses. Moreover, the results of the model are consistent over time.

Insurers have been allowed to continue to use the models, simply because they have very adequately been proven to work effectively. If they didn't work effectively in risk selection, they would have ditched the models. But that's not the case. In fact, as time has passed and court cases were won, the number of insurers using FICO based Insurance Scoring has increased very substantially.

While The use of credit information in insurance pricing and underwriting is heavily disputed - The correlation, between credit-based insurance scores and overall insurance profitability and loss, has not been disputed.
Copyright 1996-2019 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us