The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investment Analysis Clubs / The BMW Method


Subject:  Re: What happened to BMW? Date:  10/30/2018  5:51 PM
Author:  TMFMurph Number:  42252 of 42343

Hi GreenChiles!

Jim gave his heart, soul and intellect to this board for many a year.....and then tried to stretch his theories beyond where he had been (to different kinds of stocks...aka higher risk)....and failed. That may have been predictable, but the final straw for a man who gave of himself so unselfishly were (what I consider) unfair criticisms and pot shots due to said "failure"

Having hosted the very first BMWM conference in Charleston, as well as having attended most of the others, I can attest to Jim being a perfect gentleman, admitting that he did not know everything and learning as he taught.

The interesting thing is that, had one followed Jim's original BMWM method (only solid balance sheet blue chip companies like JNJ, etc,) and doubled down on them as he originally proposed, during the 2007-2009 Great recession, one would have done quite well....which I did....thanks to Jim.

The BMWM charts, which Mike Klein, an original attendee at the first conference, generously continues to maintain, continue to be an important screen for me which identify stocks for further due diligence ( I can still hear Jim making that point about DUK...that it's stock price was down in buying territory, but that one had to know the "why" of it being down before buying). Denny Schlesinger, who has never attended a conference since he lives in Venezuela, continues to maintain the BMWM website, complete with adjustable buy/sell screens....awesome!

Moral of the story: it takes a lot less energy to tear things down/criticize, than it does to create.....and folks that have given so much of themselves, often respond to hindsight and cherry-picked criticisms with a shrug of the shoulders....and hurt feelings.

Sadly, I haven't heard from Jim in years; I hope he and his bride are well.

Cheers....and fond memories of investors helping investors:

PRO and MFPP Home Fool
(long Jim, Mike and Denny...and the BMWM if used as originally intended)
Copyright 1996-2020 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us