The Motley Fool Discussion Boards

Previous Page

Investing/Strategies / Retirement Investing

URL:  https://boards.fool.com/no-withdrawals-are-made-at-the-marginal-rate-34854215.aspx

Subject:  Re: Can't do Roth anymore... Date:  6/14/2021  5:36 PM
Author:  PSUEngineer Number:  103189 of 104258

No, withdrawals are made at the marginal rate.

You keep saying this, but it is wrong. If you withdraw an additional $100, you pay 12%/22%/24% additional tax, even if your effective rate is 7%.

All you need to do is google it. "The marginal tax rate is the tax rate paid on the next dollar of income."


intercst correctly provided a good summary. Also you put into your own reply the exact situation.

My contributions are made at my marginal rate. By that, I mean my decision to invest through 401k/Roth 401k are on my last dollars earned. Either I use the 401k as a pre-tax contributions or make after-tax Roth 401k contributions. Since my marginal rate is 32%, I'm making 401k contributions.

Let's assume the tax rates don't change even though they have a sunset date. Also assume intercst is correct in that most of my retirement income will be 401k withdrawals. My 401k withdrawal will first have to fill the 12%/22%/24% marginal brackets before my first dollar is taxed at 32%. For joint returns in 2021, our income will need to exceed $329k before it starts getting taxed at 32%.

For your situation to be correct (withdrawals are made at the marginal rate), then I'll need to have other income of $329k before I make a 401k withdrawal.

PSU
Copyright 1996-2021 trademark and the "Fool" logo is a trademark of The Motley Fool, Inc. Contact Us