No. of Recommendations: 0
also Travailler is an er verb,the endings are e,es,e,ons ez,ent,therefore it should be Il travaille aux champs for he is working in the fields....Neal
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 0
Saul:

<<Il est toujours sensible à son charme>>

Why is it not "a sa charme" if the translation is "he is sensitive to her charm?"

How do you type all the French accent marks, etc. on your keyboard?

ZuZu3
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 1
Charme is a masculine word so it's son charme.

French is different than English that way. In English it's the subject that determines as in

He loves his son
He loves his daughter
She loves her son
She loves her daughter


In French it's the object that gives the gender:

Il aime son fils
Il aime sa fille.
Elle aime son fils
Elle aime sa fille.
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 0
Saul, thanks for the explanation. Since the object determines the gender of the preceding pronoun, how would differentiate in French between "Do you know HIS son" versus "Do you know HER son?"
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 1
They are both " son fils"

English has the other ambiguity: If you say his child, or his cat, you don't know if the child or cat is masculine or feminine.

French has other oddities. For example. if you refer to a person, the word personne is always feminine, even if the person is a man.

Jean est la personne qui était à la cinéma - Jean is the person who was at the cinema.
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 2
Jean est la personne qui était à la cinéma

Noun gender strikes again!
Cinéma is a masculine noun. cinémathèque (which no one uses) would be feminine.

Thus the above should be: Jean est la personne qui était au cinéma

Interesting side note:
"à la" roughly meaning "at the" for a feminine word is acceptable.
"à le" for a masculine word is incorrect. It is "au"
"à les" for plural nouns is also incorrect. It is "aux" with x denoting the plural

Il est à la maison - He is home
Ils vons au parc - They are going to the park
Il travail aux champs - He is working in the fields.

I haven't put this much thought in the language since high school!

PalmettoDude
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 0
Cinéma is a masculine noun.

Thanks Dude, I should have known that. As opposed to Spanish and Italian, "a" is a fairly masculine ending in French (except for words imported from Spanish and Italian like pizza, mafia, polenta, which are feminine).


Ils vons au parc - They are going to the park

Ils vont au parc. (Complicated language)


Saul
Print the post Back To Top
No. of Recommendations: 0
also Travailler is an er verb,the endings are e,es,e,ons ez,ent,therefore it should be Il travaille aux champs for he is working in the fields....Neal
Print the post Back To Top