Skip to main content
Message Font: Serif | Sans-Serif
 
No. of Recommendations: 4
Here's something that I wrote on this subject this morning for anyone who is interested:

"<b)The SEC "solves" its screw-up by screwing up again

Wow what a morning. There's lots of news out there. I have been trying to get my hands around what has happened and what it all means. First I will talk about what a disgrace the SEC is. I am completely disgusted with Chris Cox and his friends there. They all should be fired, without packages immediately.

I somewhat understand the need for the temporary ban on short selling, but it should have never gotten to this point. Let me explain.

Yes, many of the companies that the government has had to bail out or that have gone bankrupt were in bad shape and may have eventually gone belly-up anyhow...but hedge funds were accelerating this process to hyper-speed. Here's how they were doing it. They started by floating rumors out there and buying up Credit Default Swaps on companies. When traders and the idiotic ratings agencies (who are as much to blame as anyone for this mess) saw the CDS prices explode they said "wow, this company must really be in trouble" and its stock began to freefall. At the same time that the funds were buying up the CDSs, they were shorting the he-two-sticks out of the company's common stock...accelerating its decline. Hedge funds were going through and picking off companies one at a time. It would have continued and it was creating massive panic, so something had to happen. Unfortunately as usual, the government went too far.

The SEC already had rules on the books to prevent the sort of "naked" short selling that has been absolutely hammering stocks...yet it never enforced them. Furthermore, the SEC eliminated the "uptick" rule so now hedge funds can continue to pound on stocks hammer them into oblivion. If the uptick rule had remained in place and the naked shorting and rumor starting rules been actually enforced this short of rapid targeted destruction of individual companies would not have happened.

Instead of fixing its mistakes, now the SEC has gone way too far in the other direction by banning the short selling of 799 financial stocks (why couldn't they find one more company and just make it an even 800). Where do we live again? Russia, where they can just close the market arbitrarily for days at a time. This is the United States of America and we are supposed to have free markets. Shorting is a necessary part of that...within reason. If the SEC had taken the steps that I outlined above we would have never gotten into this mess so quickly. What does the short selling ban accomplish anyhow? Anyone who really wants to short these companies will just wait until the ban is over and then hammer away. Good greif. These companies still have all sorts of problems. Oh yeah, that's right the government is going to buy all of their bad paper. That should fix things...for them but not the citizens of this country. Hopefully later I will talk about the governments mind-blowing purchase of everything on Earth and its implications for the taxpayer, the economy, and the U.S. dollar.

Oh well, I wasn't short anything anyhow so it's nice to see some green in my portfolio today."

And here is a reply that I made to someone who was asking how short selling causes companies to go bankrupt:

" Thanks for reading, Russell. The way that hedge funds speed up the process of a company going bankrupt is they destroy clients' confidence in it. Let's take Lehman for example. The people who did business with Lehman saw what was happening with its stock and they decided that it would be safer to do business with someone else who was in better shape. No clients means no revenue to service debt and fund operations.

At the other end of the spectrum we have AIG. The massive purchasing of CDS and shorting of stock convinced ratings agencies that something was wrong with it. This caused the inept ratings agencies to downgrade or at least consider downgrading it. The downgrade triggered clauses that force AIG to have more collateral which it was unable to obtain when fear rules and the credit markets are seized up.

These are just two examples of how shorting sped up the destruction of companies.

Deej"

Short selling should not be banned, but its abuse should be prevented. A competent SEC would have been able to do this.

Deej
Print the post  

Announcements

What was Your Dumbest Investment?
Share it with us -- and learn from others' stories of flubs.
When Life Gives You Lemons
We all have had hardships and made poor decisions. The important thing is how we respond and grow. Read the story of a Fool who started from nothing, and looks to gain everything.
Contact Us
Contact Customer Service and other Fool departments here.
Work for Fools?
Winner of the Washingtonian great places to work, and Glassdoor #1 Company to Work For 2015! Have access to all of TMF's online and email products for FREE, and be paid for your contributions to TMF! Click the link and start your Fool career.