I've read all the posts so far and I seem to be missing something. I'm not seeing how this board will be anything that the REHP board isn't, except more restrictive. Maybe that's the point, and that isn't necessarily a bad thing. If I understand correctly, the focus of this board is to focus on how to achieve your ER dreams while the REHP board is more broadly focused on just about anything related to ER. Do I have this right?If I'm right about the intent of this board, I don't see how it will be any easier to keep it from going OT than the REHP board, but I would suggest we all reach consensus early on things not to discuss and then post that list in a FAQ or something. For example, if discussing politics is a no-no (even when the political topic touches on the subject of ER), then we might want to put that on a list and refer people to that list when they get into a political discussion. If somebody starts to get too deep into 72(t) SEPPs, then they can be referred over to the REHP board. Of course this is just my $.02, but if the REHP was too general, then I think this board will need some more guidance on how to be appropriately restrictive.I've seen lots of boards ruined by being overrun by hot button topics such as religion, politics, the meat eaters vs. the vegans and a whole host of other us vs. them conflicts. Perhaps this board can have recognized Problem Post categories that could be triggered so The Fool can help with some of the filtering.If I can be permitted to make some suggestions, these are a few of the things I would consider inappropriate for a board focused on how to achieve ER dreams.1. Politics. (refer to Political Asylum)2. Indepth mathematical analysis of ER. (refer to REHP)3. Tax law and tax policy. (refer to REHP)4. Bragging about investment strategies. (Refer to Bears vs. Bulls)5. Personal stock lists. (who cares?)6. Discussing corporate mentality.One last thing, all the references to the Tropics and opening bars gave me the impression that one such as myself who has no interest in the Tropics or the headaches of owning a bar would not be welcome here. I hope this is not the case. I'm no parrothead (I'm closer to being a deadhead (no Al Gore comments please)), but I do like Jimmy's music and I have blown out a flipflop by stepping on a poptop. :-)I have acheived my ER dream and if the responses to this post show sufficient tolerance for people who normally won't go below 35 degrees North latitiude, I'll share my secrets.1HappyFool
Let me respond as to the way I see this board going. I'll also preface this by saying that as I mentioned in an early post, this board will be what everyone decides to make it, good or bad.My idea was just that it is more fun to talk about the reasons why you seek early retirement, rather that the actual mechanics behind it. Obviously, to ignore the mechanics would be silly, but sometimes it seems as though we are making money for the sake of making money without expressing the underlying motivation. And why shouldn't you?So, thats why I recommended this board. I want to see what all you happy investors want to do with all your fortunes. I want to see lots of happy Fools gainfully unemployed. And you DON'T have to like Jimmy Buffett's music, but you DO have to like Jimmy's approach to life.As to restricting categories, I'm open to it. I was kind of hoping this board would lend itself to such a boat drink-like feel that those restrictions wouldn't be necessary. If you and others think they are, it doesn't bother me in the least.You are very welcome on this board. We need mentors, like you, who have reached their early retirement goals to explain how they did it to newbies like me who just want to open a bar in a warm climate.Hope to see you and Bouna Fortuna,Gekko II
HappyFool, I think that between you and Gekko this board has been pretty well defined. I especially agree with your points about keeping the politics, the math and the tax policy off of this board.I see this as being a lighter and more fun place than the RE board.
dirkn said: HappyFool, I think that between you and Gekko this board has been pretty well defined. I especially agree with your points about keeping the politics, the math and the tax policy off of this board. I see this as being a lighter and more fun place than the RE board. Me too...Chuck
I see this as being a lighter and more fun place than the RE board. Are shoes optional? I sure hope so.
Best Of |
Favorites & Replies |
Start a New Board |
My Fool |