Skip to main content
Message Font: Serif | Sans-Serif
No. of Recommendations: 10
I joined Hidden Gems to learn how to evaluate stocks on my own. Here is
my first valuation attempt at CNS using Matt Richey's technique in the
write-up but with the latest financial information. Please feel free to
comment because that is how I am going to learn. 

My process: I started by getting the SFCF (less investment income) and
looked at the y-o-y growth: it grew 4%. I then looked at the diluted
share count y-o-y: it grew 3%. I applied this 3% dilution rate to each
of the next 3 years reaching a total of 15.9M diluted shares in FY07.

Net SFCF grew 1% y-o-y from FY03 to FY04(4% SFCF - 3% dilution).I applied
this 1% growth rate to the next 3 years (which is very conservative
because the analysts are expecting the eps to grow 10% in FY05 on a
fully diluted basis). That gets us 0.761 SFCF per share by FY07. If I
apply the multiple of 12X and 15X that Matt Richey used in the write up
(is this really an accurate multiple to apply if I am assuming only a
1% SFCF growth?) then I get a price of $9.137-$11.421 per share.

If I assume the SFCF for FY05-FY07 drops to the CASH line then I get a total cash
balance of $84.377M in FY07. That equates to a $5.30 per share in cash alone in

If I add the cash to the 12X and 15X price per share I get a value of
the company at $14.44-$16.73 three years out (13%-19% annual growth)
from where the stock price is today. 

I believe this is a very conservative valuation because it simply
assumes CNS can continue the same level of growth it did last year -
while the analysts are expecting bigger things. Even at this
conservative valuation a 13%-19% annual growth will most likely beat
the market over that time.

I think this is a good time to buy. Anyone else?

	                             FY03	 FY04	Incr.	  FY05	  FY06	  FY07		
Net Income	                    6,516       8,547 	  31%					
Depreciation & Amortization	    1,251 	  958 	 -23%					
Deferred Income Taxes	            3,489 	2,468 	 -29%					
Capital Expenditures	             (60)        (478)	 697%					
Structural Free Cash Flow	   11,196 	11,495 	   3%					
Investment Income	             (839)	 (725)	 -14%					
SFCF less Investment Income	   10,357 	10,770 	   4%					
Diluted Share Count	           14,044 	14,488 	   3%	 14,946   15,419   15,906 		
Incr. Diluted Shares 				                   458      473      487 		
(assuming 3% dilution)								
SFCF per share	                    0.737 	 0.743 	   1%	  0.749    0.755    0.761	
Multiple of 12X						                            9.137 per share	
Multiple of 15X			                                                    11.421 per share	
Cash + Marketable Securities	   41,615 	 49,421    19%	 60,620   72,267   84,377 		
Incremental Cash				                 11,199   11,646   12,110 		
Cash + Mrktbl Securities per share				   4.06    4.69    5.30 per share	
Business Value at 12X 						                   14.44 13%annual returns
Business Value at 15X 		                                	           16.73 19%annual returns
(SFCF/share + Cash/share)								
Print the post  


What was Your Dumbest Investment?
Share it with us -- and learn from others' stories of flubs.
When Life Gives You Lemons
We all have had hardships and made poor decisions. The important thing is how we respond and grow. Read the story of a Fool who started from nothing, and looks to gain everything.
Contact Us
Contact Customer Service and other Fool departments here.
Work for Fools?
Winner of the Washingtonian great places to work, and Glassdoor #1 Company to Work For 2015! Have access to all of TMF's online and email products for FREE, and be paid for your contributions to TMF! Click the link and start your Fool career.